Putting People First.

Auto, Home, Farm & Small Business Insurance for all of Central New York

Insurance Made for Central New York

from Central New York

The mission of Jordan First Insurance is to provide local, independent insurance solutions to the rural communities in Central New York

We offer our unique underwriting solutions focusing on three main sectors of insurance: Property, Small Business & Agriculture

Our Full Product Line

Image by FourFour

Autos & More

  • Personal Auto

  • Motorcycle

  • ATV

  • Snowmobile

  • Boat

  • Travel Trailer & RV

  • Heavy Equipment

Image by Aubrey Odom-Mabey

Homes & Dwellings

  • Homeowners

  • Landlords

  • Seasonal Cottages

  • Short-Term Rental (Airbnb)

  • Vacant/Under Renovation

  • Mobile & Manufactured 

Image by Timothy Eberly

Farm & Ag

  • Crop Farms

  • Livestock Farms

  • Hobby Farming

  • Specialty Equipment

  • Cannabis Production

  • Aqua Culturing

  • Horse Boarding

Image by Adam Winger

Small Business

  • General Liability

  • Commercial Property

  • Worker's Compensation

  • NYS Disability & PFL

  • Business Auto

  • Trucking & Transportation

  • Professional Liability

Request a Quote
I need quotes on...

Your request has been sent. An agent will reach out to you shortly.


Meet Your Host

The Haines Family and the Village of Jordan have a history together - one of beginnings.

I was born in Jordan at 61 N Main St and raised in Skaneateles when it was time for school.
My father was a member of the Jordan Lodge, my mother graduated from J-E - class of '75.

I've lived in Buffalo since 2009, but I never forgot about that small-town CNY life that I was raised with. When I purchased Encompass Agency in late 2020, it was a dream of mine to bring part of my operation back home for folks that deserve better than a call center.

The idea of putting a location in Jordan came before all others.

A quaint village, nestled in off Rt. 31 where time sometimes seems to stand still.

Everyone knows everyone, and people are appreciative of the small things.

In honor of Jordan's heritage, a throwback to the canal boom days of a thriving rural town, I decided on the name Jordan First - making sure you know that your family, your property and your livelihood come first to me.

To all the small towns out there - I hope to meet you soon and earn your business,


Taylor M Haines, CEO


News & Updates


Zachary Tavolaro, General Manager


cherie haines_edited_edited_edited.jpg

Cherie Haines, Marketing